I can’t remember when I found this mascara, maybe about ten years ago. I’m a die-hard because every type of mascara, no matter how waterproof, would smudge under my eyes not even an hour later. I looked drunk, or something…This mascara comes off in little tubes, so it doesn’t smear like other mascaras. It’s all I ever use. Every time I walk past a Sephora, I’ll pick up another one.